Publishers and Editing

Every publisher has a different stance on editing - and the same publisher might edit different books in a very different manner. Some publishers use the red pen liberally, completely rewriting a book into the way THEY will feel will sell. Remember, in many ways they don't worry much about what the author wanted to accomplish. Their aim is for the book to sell as widely as possible. So they will use their background and knowledge to make changes - both in grammer and in tone - to accomplish that aim.

My publisher, Windstorm Creative, didn't edit my three books at ALL. Now, I've read that they do edit other peoples' books. I had a very high quality editor go over all my books numerous times before they were submitted to Windstorm. So it could be that the books were in "final shape" before Windstorm got them. It could be that Windstorm just edits lightly, and mine were fine as is, while others only needed minor tweaking. Some people get really upset over even tiny changes. Some people don't mind.

I personally really wanted them to DO some editing. I figured that is why they were getting a cut of the profits - because of their editing expertise. As it was, all they did was layout of the books and then of course the up-front printing costs. I suppose I should be grateful that they did not "destroy" my works with their editing, but I think I would have been more happy if it seemed they put a little effort into reading them.

From Terrie - Homeschooling Author
When working with most publishers, you will be asked to make a huge number of changes. This surprises and upsets first time authors. Don't get so attached to your book you can't follow their suggestions--they know what sells. Only protest when it's morally important to you, such as when they want you to recommend something you don't approve of.

I've heard the trend for some publishers is to not edit, that it should arrive perfect. That's one thing I like about my publisher--lots of help.

Getting Your Book Published
Writing Tips and Online Books

Online Literary Magazines

Lisa Shea's Homepage