dystopian western cover

Do you prefer left or right? I’m considering a complete change in direction for my dystopian western cover. The 5-star reviews all praise its quiet Western feel – but my current cover (left) makes it look more like a zombie apocalypse :). So I think I might be driving away people who seek that gentle horseback in the plains storyline. Still, I think the left one is more eye-catching, so I’m torn. I do understand that drawing in the “wrong audience” doesn’t do me much good for all sorts of reasons.